316 versus 430 SS application - Steel and Stainless ...

24 Jun.,2024

 

316 versus 430 SS application - Steel and Stainless ...

INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

If you want to learn more, please visit our website 316 stainless steel welded wire mesh.

Contact US

FIRST NAME

*


LAST NAME

*


*


MESSAGE

*


ADDITIONAL DETAILS

Thanks. We have received your request and will respond promptly.

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!

  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
Join Us!

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving . By joining you are opting in to receive .

Posting Guidelines



Students Click Here

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Eng-Tips Posting Policies

Contact US

thread723- Forum Search FAQs Links MVPs
  • Forum

  • Search

  • FAQs

  • Links

  • MVPs

316 versus 430 SS application

316 versus 430 SS application

schnipp

(Chemical)

(OP)

19 Nov 08 12:34

Where would I find relative differences between 316 and 430 stainless?

I have a basket centrifuge that we currently use 316 SS perforated screen and wire mesh backing that we want to consider using 430 series stainless due to the higher magnetic property (food grade application).

The question was posed about the brittleness and maleability between the two as it takes a fair amount of tugging and pulling to get the perforated screen installed.  Since the mechanic is inside the basket of a centrifuge, there isn't always the most room to get a good grip.

Thanks for the assistance.

RE: 316 versus 430 SS application

EdStainless

(Materials)

19 Nov 08 13:02
The properties for 430 can cover a very wide range depending on the Carbon content and heat treatment.
430 will be much more ferromagnetic than 316.
430 will have less corrosion resistance than 316, more similar to 304.
430 will have less ductility than 316, but it may not be enough less to matter.

I suppose that your supplier has offered this alternative. If so you should ask them for some actual test reports on the properties of the alloys.The properties for 430 can cover a very wide range depending on the Carbon content and heat treatment.430 will be much more ferromagnetic than 316.430 will have less corrosion resistance than 316, more similar to 304.430 will have less ductility than 316, but it may not be enough less to matter.

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Plymouth Tube

RE: 316 versus 430 SS application

schnipp

(Chemical)

(OP)

19 Nov 08 13:06

The greater ferromagnetic is what we're after, so that magnets down stream capture anything that may be shed in the centrifuge.
The corrosion resistance isn't a concern, as the product is not that corrosive.
If the ductility isn't that much less than the 316 we're currently using, we should be fine.

The supplier currently sells 430 in increasing amounts to other users, so I'm optimistic it will work.

We're going to try a few and see how they hold up and go from there.

Thanks for the reply, EdStainless.

RE: 316 versus 430 SS application

EdStainless

(Materials)

19 Nov 08 16:00
If so insist on seeing mechanical property tests for the welds.
This may be easier to pull out later, but that is no reason to accept the risk of having more metal end up in the system due to breakage.

Are these screens welded to frames?If so insist on seeing mechanical property tests for the welds.This may be easier to pull out later, but that is no reason to accept the risk of having more metal end up in the system due to breakage.

= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Plymouth Tube

RE: 316 versus 430 SS application

schnipp

(Chemical)

(OP)

Want more information on Best Fence for Cattle? Feel free to contact us.

19 Nov 08 16:11

No, the speeds in the centrifuge pretty much set them in (~ rpm).  Metal ends up in the process if something goes wrong, usually a plow tip goes a little deeper than it is supposed to.

 

RE: 316 versus 430 SS application

unclesyd

(Materials)

19 Nov 08 19:26

Please do not attempt to weld 430 SS. I weld and HAZ will be very brittle after welding without heat treatment.

Could you possibly state what your process material is as 430 SS is very good in some services and extremely poor in others?  

RE: 316 versus 430 SS application

schnipp

(Chemical)

(OP)

20 Nov 08 08:17

We're processing crystalline destrose.  We don't weld the screens in, the screen folds and essentially snaps into place.  

 

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.


Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members! Already a Member? Login



News


Helpful hints for buying wire mesh

Since , Edward J. Darby & Son, Inc. has been an industry leader in the global wire mesh market. From our custom manufacturing capabilities to our extremely robust and varied inventory, Darby is a fixture in the wire mesh industry and remains a preferred source for both large industrial users and small fabrication shops, alike. In keeping with the changing global marketplace and listening to the challenges many of our customers face, we would like to take this opportunity to share four (4) tips for keeping your wire mesh costs down.

Other Frequently Asked Questions

Edward J. Darby & Son, Inc. has developed a list of answers to some of the most asked questions we have received over the years. For questions and answers not discussed here, please contact us for more information. For questions related to wire mesh, please visit the wire mesh glossary or the wire mesh overview pages.

Do you offer blind shipments & drop shipments?

Edward J. Darby & Son, Inc. has been a major player in the wire mesh industry for over 160 years, and as a result, we have earned a reputation for honesty and trust. To that end, Darby offers both blind shipments and drop shipments. These special shipments ship directly from our facility to our customer&#;s customer, which saves both of them time and money. Blind shipments are ideal for customers who do not want to reveal the source&#;s name to their customers. We have worked with UPS and various motor freight carriers to enhance our customized blind shipment program. This program allows us to set up and schedule blind shipments and keep sensitive information private. We routinely use generic shipping labels and can easily use our customer&#;s own, if desired.

What is your cancellation policy?

Once an order is placed &#; verbally, via purchase order, or through e-commerce&#;Darby immediately begins to fill your order. Darby requests that you double check your specifications, quantity and dimensions before placing your order.

Orders that can be cancelled may be subject to a minimum cancellation charge of 25%. However, certain orders, including custom manufacturing, fabricated parts and cut-to-size pieces, are non-cancellable.

What is your chemical & physical certification policy?

Edward J. Darby & Son, Inc. can offer chemical and/or physical certification for most any woven or welded wire mesh. A request for Darby&#;s standard chemical and/or physical certification must be clearly stated on your official written purchase order. Unfortunately, in most cases, we are unable to provide certifications more than 60 days after the order ships.

For any non-standard or specialized certification, including, but not limited to, statements of DFAR and/or USA manufacture, Country of Melt, ROHS compliance, Conflict of Materials (Dodd-Frank), LEED, magnetic permeability, or a particular industrial specification, the request must be clearly communicated in the original request for quote (RFQ) and clearly stated on the official purchase order. In order to comply with these special certification requests, additional charges may apply. Please speak to a sales person or a quality control representative for more information.

What is your damaged shipment policy?

Upon receipt of your wire mesh shipment, it is the customer&#;s responsibility to inspect the package for any external damage. If external damage is found, the delivery receipt and other associated paperwork must note the damage before accepting the delivery. A photo in these instances is highly recommended. After opening the package, if the material is damaged, a claim must be made with the carrier. Filing the claim and requesting an inspection in a prompt fashion are the responsibilities of the customer.

Do you offer expediting services?

Darby understands that there are times when our customers &#;need material yesterday.&#; As a result, we offer numerous expediting services including same day shipments, rush delivery, pick-ups, and expediting fabrication. Because of our extensive inventory and devoted staff, we routinely ship stock material out the day your order is placed. We utilize UPS World Ship which allows us to ship material out Express Critical, Next Day Air, Second Day Air and UPS Ground. We also work closely with various motor freight carriers and same day courier services to make sure our customers receive material when it is needed. Surcharges may apply to some expediting requests; please contact us with your expediting requirements.

Because we understand today&#;s business climate, Darby also provides quick turnaround on most quotations.

What are your quality standards?

Most wire mesh that Darby supplies adheres to the standard specification for industrial woven wire cloth, namely ASTM-E-11. It is important for any purchaser of wire mesh and wire cloth to be familiar with this specification, which can be accessed online at www.astm.org. This specification discusses quality standards within the wire mesh industry.

ASTM E--11 states that wire cloth &#;shall be woven with first-class workmanship, although some blemishes or defects are inherent in the weaving process.&#; Darby understands its role as a major supplier of wire mesh and wire cloth and abides by a specially designed quality initiative that aims to consistently provide its customers with high quality wire mesh.

Wire mesh is an industrial product and is intended for use in industrial applications, where functionality is the primary objective. Because mesh is an extremely versatile product, it is often used in applications not related to industrial use, for example in instances where appearance is critical.

Generally speaking, Darby is unable to guarantee perfect, or defect-free, material. Blemishes or defects are inherent in the weaving process and are virtually impossible to avoid. We encourage all customers who may have stringent quality requirements to discuss them with a sales representative and to review the permissible blemishes detailed in ASTM E--11, if applicable. We routinely work with these types of customers and have been largely successful in meeting their requirements.

What are your quantity tolerances?

Most wire mesh that Darby supplies adheres to the standard specification for industrial woven wire cloth, namely ASTM-E-11. It is important for any purchaser of wire mesh and wire cloth to be familiar with this specification, which can be accessed online at www.astm.org. This specification discusses tolerances in the wire mesh industry, in detail.

Two of the more popular discussion points related to quantity tolerance are full roll purchases and fabricated parts.

ASTM E--11 designates that a standard roll shall be 100 linear feet, +/- 10 linear feet; the roll may consist of up to three pieces, no pieces less than 10 linear feet. For example, an acceptable roll can consist of 1 piece, 50 feet, 1 piece, 30 feet, and 1 piece, 20 feet.

On custom manufactured items, including, but not limited to discs, cut-to-size pieces, and fabricated parts, there is a quantity variance of +/- 10%. All other variances must be agreed to prior to the acceptance of a purchase order.

Should a customer have any specific quantity tolerances, it should be discussed with Darby. For a more detailed look into tolerances, please visit www.astm.org.

What is your return policy?

From its inception in to today, Edward J. Darby & Son, Inc. has been committed to supplying high quality, industrial grade wire mesh. After receiving material and before cutting to size, fabricating or shipping, it is important that Darby&#;s customer inspect material to confirm it is received as ordered. Darby is unable to accept a return on any mesh that has been processed or modified.

Should the quality of mesh be in question, the disparity must be noted in writing within 10 days of delivery date. At that point, Darby will have the option to issue a Return Goods Authorization with shipping instructions. The customer is responsible for shipping costs back to Darby, unless the dispute is an error in Darby&#;s fulfillment of the order.

Darby reserves the right to inspect material before issuing credit, refund or replacement. Darby will inspect the material for non-conformance, including tolerances, defects and blemishes referenced in ASTM E--11, or other applicable industrial standards. After inspection, should the material not conform to the applicable industrial standard, Darby issue a refund for /replacement of material and reasonable transportation costs.

Full, unprocessed, rolls that are authorized for return will be subject to a restocking fee. Darby may be unable to accept returns on incorrectly ordered items, mesh that has been cut, fabricated parts or custom manufactured items.

Do you offer special packaging requirements?

Often times, users of wire mesh require special packaging for their material. Some of the more popular packing requirements include: individually packaged and marked shipments, flat shipments, shipment with extra protection, consolidated shipments and customized boxed. Please contact us to discuss your special packaging requirements. Extra charges may apply.

Do you offer wire mesh analysis?

If you have a piece of mesh that you are looking to identify or even replicate, look no further than Edward J. Darby & Son, Inc. Our team of knowledgeable and experienced technicians has the ability to identify virtually any woven or welded mesh you may have.

We commonly identify mesh count, diameter wire, opening size and percentage of open area. We are happy to offer this service, free of charge. We also have the capabilities to distinguish specific alloys and chemical compositions; additional charges for this service may apply.

Can you make specific wire mesh recommendations?

This website has been designed with the goal of providing website visitors with all of the detailed information we have learned from our broad range of customers over the years. More importantly, this website has been developed to serve as a guide to assist in the decision making process for the purchase of wire mesh.

We are unable to make specific wire mesh recommendations for a specific application. If you are unsure about what mesh will work best in your application, we suggest sampling, prototyping or speaking to an expert or engineer in your particular industry.

Sample Policy

To learn about our Sample Policy, please visit here:

More Information Sample Policy

If you are looking for more details, kindly visit Ebb and Flow Benches for Sale.